On the 8th I mentioned that I was reading David Hicks’s recently published account of his life. I now find myself preparing a review for the December South Sydney Herald.
In addition to the reviews linked to the earlier post I have been examining other resources on the subject of David Hicks. Any review of his book must include reference to the documentary The President Versus David Hicks. David Stratton:
The troubling documentary ‘The President Versus David Hicks’, which screened on SBS earlier this year and is only now getting a cinema release, is in effect a profile of David Hicks’ father, Terry. Faced with a situation no parent should have to contemplate, his son imprisoned for years by a foreign power which won’t allow his family access, his own government refusing to intervene on behalf of its citizen. Terry Hicks sets off, accompanied by film-maker Curtis Levy, to follow in his son’s footsteps in an effort to find out what happened to him.
We discover that David, a seemingly average Aussie kid from Adelaide, son of a broken marriage and with a failed relationship, and two children, behind him, converted to Islam and determined to fight what he saw as injustice towards Muslims, first in Kosovo, then in Kashmir and finally Afghanistan, where he became increasingly radicalised.
Terry Hicks is a wonderful character, a real Aussie battler, and very tolerant of some of the less attractive things he discovers about his son during his odessy. The film was made before David Hicks was formally charged, but it still raises once again all the questions about justice, respect for international law and the apparent indifference of Australian authorities to the fate of one of their citizens. This is a documentary which every concerned Australian should see…
The letters used in that documentary are glossed over somewhat in the recent book.
There has also been an opportunity to look again at the thoroughly admirable Michael Mori.
I’ve often wondered what became of Mori later. Here is the answer from Wikipedia.
Following Hicks’ departure from Guantanamo Bay to complete his sentence in Yatala Prison, South Australia – on or about May 20, 2007 – Mori was re-assigned as a staff judge advocate, or legal adviser, to the commanders of Marine Corps Air Station Miramar in San Diego. He has twice been passed over for promotion since taking on the Hicks case.
Mori was presented, in June 2007, with an honorary membership of the Australian Bar Association for his defence of David Hicks. In October 2007, he was awarded a civil justice award from the Australian Lawyers Alliance as “recognition by the legal profession of unsung heroes who, despite personal risk or sacrifice, have fought to preserve individual rights, human dignity or safety”.
In September 2010, Mori took the navy to court, alleging that his 2009 promotion was delayed due to bias by the selection board.
Now that guy is a hero!
Now to that famous question:
The answer clearly is “No”.
Was David Hicks one of the “worst of the worst” as Donald Rumsfeld once famously said? No.
Was his confession genuine? No.
Was he totally innocent? No.
Should you read his book? Yes. Should you accept what he says? Cautiously and critically.
One aside: in her review (see the 8 November post) Miranda Devine pooh-poohs Hicks’s account of how he became a Muslim by checking the Adelaide yellow pages and finding a nearby mosque. Well, that one I do believe. Miranda seems to know little about how to become a Muslim, which in fact is easier than with most religions.
To become a Muslim one must simply pronounce the Shahaadatayn (Declaration of Faith) with sincerity and conviction.The Shahadah can be declared as follows:
“ASH-HADU ANLA ELAHA ILLA-ALLAH WA ASH-HADU ANNA MOHAMMADAN RASUL-ALLAH”.
The English translation is:
“I bear witness that there is no deity worthy to be worshiped but Allah, and I bear witness that Muhammad is His servant and messenger.”
All you have to do is say that twice to another Muslim and you’re in. No courses necessary.
— More on Michael Mori: Marine Times Monday Sep 20, 2010.
Making you think
The silent camera
...because the world is full of it.
Just because you CAN read Moby Dick doesn't mean you should.
This WordPress.com site is the bee's knees
Musings on poetry, language, perception, numbers, food, and anything else that slips through the cracks.
Political and Social Commentary
from The Bates Motel, West Wollongong.
Politics Made Easy!
Movies, thoughts, thoughts about movies.
News and Opinions From Inside China
#Strongwomen. "I write about the power of trying, because I want to be okay with failing. I write about generosity because I battle selfishness. I write about joy because I know sorrow. I write about faith because I almost lost mine, and I know what it is to be broken and in need of redemption. I write about gratitude because I am thankful - for all of it." Kristin Armstrong
from The Bates Motel, West Wollongong.